Right to death (Suicide) is not part of the right to life: Supreme Court of India (1996)

 

Suicide

 

Title: Gian Kaur vs The State of Punjab

Court: Supreme Court, Punjab High Court

Citation: 1996 SCC (2) 648

Decided on: 21st March, 1996

Coram: J.S. Verma, G.N. Ray, N.P. Singh, Faizan Uddin, and G.T. Nanavati JJ.

Introduction:

Gian Kaur was the widow of a soldier who died while in service. She, along with her mother, was charged with abetting the suicide of her husband. The case raised the constitutional validity of Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalizes the attempt to commit suicide. The petitioner argued that the right to life, as enshrined in Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, includes the right to die with dignity. The central question before the Supreme Court was whether the right to life also encompasses the right to terminate one’s own life.

Facts:

Gian Kaur and her husband Harbans Singh were accused in this case of encouraging their daughter-in-law “Kulwant Kaur” to commit suicide in violation of Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The couple had boldly splashed their daughter-in-law with kerosene, and they fervently wanted to see her die. Their goal was to marry their son to a different woman who could provide them with a dowry. The Trial Court found them both guilty of their actions in accordance with Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code.

They were given a six-year sentence of rigorous imprisonment and were also ordered to pay a fine of Rs. 2,000. If they failed to pay the fine, they would have been subject to another nine months of rigorous imprisonment. Furthermore, the appellants filed an appeal with the High Court, which upheld the Lower Court’s ruling affirming the appellants’ rights. Gian Kaur’s sentence, however, has been reduced from six years to three years of rigorous imprisonment. The Appellants petitioned the Supreme Court for Special Leave to overturn their conviction under Section 306 of the IPC.

Questions: 

  1. Is Section 306 of IPC constitutionally valid?
  2. Whether Article 14 and Article 21 of the Constitution of India is being violated by Section 309 of the IPC?
  3. Is “Right to Die” included under article 21 of the constitution of India which deals with the “Right to Life”?

Judgement of the Court and Analysis:

The court determined that because section 309 of the IPC excluded the right to die from its purview, it did not infringe Article 21. Moreover, it was decided that it was neither arbitrary nor brutal enough to violate Article 14. The courts are allowed to use their good judgment when imposing penalties; neither a minimum penalty nor mandatory incarceration is mandated.

The court upheld section 306 of the IPC, stating that since section 309 is constitutional and the right to die does not fall under Article 21, there is no basis for section 306 to be unlawful as well. In addition, section 306 will remain in effect even in the absence of section 309 since aiding and abetting and planning to murder are two distinct crimes.

The court also ruled that the right to death is not part of the right to life. It ensures the preservation of life, and consequently the right to live with honour till the end of one’s natural life as well as the right to a respectable funeral. But it excludes the ending of life via artificial methods, therefore suicide is not an honourable way to pass away. The argument that the freedom of expression encompasses the right to remain silent is inapplicable in the context of Article 21.

The court ruled that ending a person’s life prematurely is not within the bounds of the right to live with human dignity. Article 21, which guarantees the right to die with dignity, may apply to a person who is terminally sick or in a chronic vegetative state, but this argument is not applicable in this particular situation. Therefore, it was decided that the euthanasia argument was unnecessary. As to the court’s ruling, the legislature has the authority to decide whether or not to remove a provision that was recommended by a law commission. The legislature cannot request that the court rule the provision unconstitutional. A provision’s validity is often only contested by the pertinent sections of the constitution.

Debate about the constitutionality of the right to die has persisted for a long time. The five-judge bench in Gian Kaur declared that the right to life extended beyond the measurement of an animal’s existence. It encompassed the right to a dignified life during one’s natural course as well as the right to a dignified funeral.

On the other hand, the right to life does not entail the right to end one’s life in an unethical manner, such as by suicide. Moreover, the court determined that aiding and abetting suicide are distinct crimes, which might be highly relevant. Nobody has the right to force someone to take his life, and it cannot be justified by claiming that it is just helping to uphold a basic human right.

Therefore, whether or not Section 309 of the IPC is valid, aiding and abetting suicide is still a horrible crime. Furthermore, it’s a common misconception that India, as a state, is better suited to protect the lives of its people. It is against the state constitution to create a law that promotes the killing of its citizens.

In terms of euthanasia, the court decided that a patient in a persistent vegetative condition could have the right to pass away under certain circumstances in a dignified manner. was further emphasized in a 2018 Supreme Court ruling in the case of Common Cause v. Union of India. Consequently, the ruling in Gian Kaur’s case is still seen as significant and good judgment.

The Supreme Court of India

 

Written by: Akshaya Zavar

Unfold Law – Best law firm in Bangalore, Best criminal lawyer

 

This Post Has 222 Comments

  1. Tanu aggarwal February 27, 2024 Reply

    🔍 Explore the landmark judgment of Gian Kaur vs. The State of Punjab where the Supreme Court ruled that the right to death (suicide) is not a part of the right to life. Learn about the constitutional validity of Section 309 of the IPC and its implications on Article 21. #SupremeCourt #RightToLife 📜⚖️

  2. Warner Crouchet July 21, 2024 Reply

    Perfectly pent subject material, regards for selective information “Life is God’s novel Let him write it” by Isaac Bashevis Singer

  3. Otto Hands August 6, 2024 Reply

    Only a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw outstanding layout

  5. user-880040 October 2, 2024 Reply

    awesome

  6. binance account October 31, 2024 Reply

    Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!

  8. eco blankets November 13, 2024 Reply

    Hi there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my website to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good
    success. If you know of any please share. Kudos! You can read similar blog
    here: Eco blankets

  9. binance Registrēties November 18, 2024 Reply

    Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me.

  10. Create a free account December 29, 2024 Reply

    Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.

  11. binance January 23, 2025 Reply

    Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  12. binance h"anvisningsbonus February 23, 2025 Reply

    Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  14. 开设Binance账户 March 11, 2025 Reply

    Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me.

  15. https://codeofdestiny.art/?page_id=20 March 12, 2025 Reply

    Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to
    rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
    If you know of any please share. Thank you!
    You can read similar text here: Change your life

  16. Darrell March 26, 2025 Reply

    I am extremely impressed together with your writing talents as well as with the layout to your blog. Is this a paid subject or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice high quality writing, it is uncommon to see a great weblog like this one today. I like unfoldlaw.in ! Mine is: Snipfeed

  17. Candelaria March 27, 2025 Reply

    I am really impressed along with your writing talents and also with the layout on your blog. Is that this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice high quality writing, it is rare to peer a nice weblog like this one nowadays. I like unfoldlaw.in ! I made: Beehiiv

  18. Binance账户 April 20, 2025 Reply

    Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me.

  19. Daviddiels April 24, 2025 Reply

    kamagra gel: kamagra gel – Kamagra pharmacie en ligne

  20. Bernardswada April 25, 2025 Reply

    Pharmacie sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne pharmafst.com

  24. BradleyZew April 25, 2025 Reply

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher: Livraison rapide – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne pharmafst.com

  29. Bernardswada April 26, 2025 Reply

    Achetez vos kamagra medicaments: kamagra 100mg prix – Kamagra Commander maintenant

  31. Bernardswada April 27, 2025 Reply

    Acheter Cialis: cialis prix – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop

  32. Bernardswada April 27, 2025 Reply

    kamagra 100mg prix: kamagra en ligne – Achetez vos kamagra medicaments

  37. Bernardswada April 28, 2025 Reply

    Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher: Cialis generique prix – Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop

  45. MichaelAvect April 29, 2025 Reply

    my canadian pharmacy [url=https://expressrxcanada.com/#]ExpressRxCanada[/url] canada pharmacy online legit

  48. MichaelSok April 29, 2025 Reply

    canadian online pharmacy: Express Rx Canada – maple leaf pharmacy in canada

  49. MichaelAvect April 29, 2025 Reply

    indian pharmacy online shopping [url=https://medicinefromindia.com/#]indian pharmacy online shopping[/url] indian pharmacy online

  53. MichaelAvect April 29, 2025 Reply

    mexico pharmacy order online [url=https://rxexpressmexico.shop/#]Rx Express Mexico[/url] mexican rx online

  55. MichaelAvect April 30, 2025 Reply

    Online medicine home delivery [url=https://medicinefromindia.shop/#]MedicineFromIndia[/url] indian pharmacy

  57. BrianNog May 1, 2025 Reply

    pin up azerbaycan: pin up az – pin-up casino giris

  59. Medium Online'owe May 1, 2025 Reply

    Your ability to connect with the reader on both an intellectual and emotional level is truly rare.

  63. BrianNog May 1, 2025 Reply

    pin up casino: pinup az – pin up casino

  78. Kennethtof May 3, 2025 Reply

    pin up azerbaycan: pin-up – pin-up casino giris

  81. assassin for hire May 3, 2025 Reply

    This platform allows you to find experts for temporary risky projects.
    Visitors are able to efficiently set up help for specific situations.
    All workers have expertise in executing critical jobs.
    hire a killer
    The website guarantees private connections between employers and freelancers.
    For those needing a quick solution, this website is ready to help.
    Post your request and connect with a skilled worker now!

  91. Kennethtof May 4, 2025 Reply

    pin up: pin up – pinup az

  92. Kennethtof May 5, 2025 Reply

    пин ап казино официальный сайт: пин ап вход – pin up вход

  98. Kennethtof May 5, 2025 Reply

    pinup az: pin up az – pin up azerbaycan

  102. chinese-hitman-assassin.com May 6, 2025 Reply

    通过本平台，您可以联系专门从事单次的危险工作的专业人士。
    我们集合大量技能娴熟的工作人员供您选择。
    无论是何种危险需求，您都可以轻松找到合适的人选。
    如何雇佣刺客
    所有合作人员均经过审核，确保您的隐私。
    网站注重匿名性，让您的危险事项更加高效。
    如果您需要具体流程，请立即联系！

  106. apoma May 6, 2025 Reply

    Happy to join conversations, share experiences, and pick up new insights throughout the journey.
    I like learning from different perspectives and sharing my input when it’s helpful. Interested in hearing new ideas and building connections.
    There is my site-https://automisto24.com.ua/

  112. apoma May 7, 2025 Reply

    Happy to explore discussions, exchange ideas, and gain fresh perspectives throughout the journey.
    I enjoy learning from different perspectives and contributing whenever I can. Happy to hear fresh thoughts and meeting like-minded people.
    There’s my web-site:https://automisto24.com.ua/

  115. Elmervah May 7, 2025 Reply

    вавада официальный сайт: вавада – вавада официальный сайт

  119. Elmervah May 8, 2025 Reply

    вавада зеркало: vavada – вавада

  124. 色情网站 May 8, 2025 Reply

    访问者请注意，这是一个仅限成年人浏览的站点。
    进入前请确认您已年满十八岁，并同意了解本站内容性质。
    本网站包含限制级信息，请理性访问。 色情网站。
    若您未满18岁，请立即退出页面。
    我们致力于提供健康安全的网络体验。

  138. Wileywow May 10, 2025 Reply

    One X Bet is a premier online betting platform.
    Offering a broad variety of matches, 1XBet meets the needs of a vast audience worldwide.
    The One X Bet application created for both Android and iPhone bettors.
    https://confidantclasses.in/pages/kak_organizovaty_pomolvku.html
    It’s possible to download the 1xBet app via their site or Play Store on Android devices.
    For iOS users, this software can be installed via the official iOS store easily.

  179. Scottvof May 17, 2025 Reply

    when will cialis become generic: cialis vs.levitra – when to take cialis for best results

  181. Scottvof May 17, 2025 Reply

    what is cialis used to treat: Tadal Access – cheapest cialis online

  185. 강남가라오케 May 17, 2025 Reply

    최저가격보장선릉셔츠룸선릉셔츠룸가격정보

  187. 강남가라오케 May 17, 2025 Reply

    최저가격보장강남셔츠룸강남셔츠룸가격정보

  188. 강남가라오케 May 17, 2025 Reply

    최저가격보장CNN셔츠룸씨엔엔셔츠룸가격정보

  189. 강남가라오케 May 17, 2025 Reply

    최저가격보장강남룸싸롱강남룸싸롱가격정보

  190. Scottvof May 17, 2025 Reply

    where can i buy cialis over the counter: Tadal Access – over the counter cialis 2017

  222. binance May 24, 2025 Reply

    Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.

Leave a Reply