Title: Sita Soren v/s Union of India
Court: The Supreme Court of India
Case no.: Criminal Appeal No 451 of 2019
Decided on: September 20, 2023
Coram: Before Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, C.J. and A.S. Bopanna, M.M. Sundresh, J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.
Introduction
An election was held on March 30, 2012, for two members of the Rajya Sabha representing the State of Jharkhand. The appellant was a member of the Legislative Assembly belonging to the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha. The allegation against the appellant is that she accepted a bribe from an independent candidate to cast her vote in his favor.
However, as revealed by the open balloting for the Rajya Sabha seat, she did not cast her vote in favor of the alleged bribe giver. Instead, she cast her vote in favor of a candidate from her own party. She was charged with taking a bribe, and the State prosecuted her. She appealed to a three-judge bench in the High Court of Jharkhand.
Brief Facts:
An election was held on March 30, 2012, for two members of the Rajya Sabha representing the State of Jharkhand. The appellant was a member of the Legislative Assembly belonging to the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha. The allegation against the appellant is that she accepted a bribe from an independent candidate to cast her vote in his favor.
However, as revealed by the open balloting for the Rajya Sabha seat, she did not cast her vote in favor of the alleged bribe giver. Instead, she cast her vote in favor of a candidate from her own party. The round of the election in question was rescinded, and a fresh election was held, during which the appellant voted in favor of the candidate from her own party.
The appellant moved the High Court to quash the charge-sheet and the criminal proceedings instituted against her. The appellant relied on the provisions of Article 194(2) of the Constitution. The High Court, in the impugned judgment, declined to quash the criminal proceedings on the grounds that the appellant had not cast her vote in favor of the alleged bribe giver, and thus, was not entitled to the protection under Article 194(2).
The three-judge Bench hearing the present appeal was of the view that, “having regard to the wide ramifications of the question that has arisen, the doubts raised, and the issue being a matter of public importance,” it required referral to a larger Bench, as may be considered appropriate. Accordingly, the matter has been placed, pursuant to the administrative directions of the Chief Justice of India, before this Bench of five judges.
Question: (1) whether Politicians (MPs/MLAs) are immune from bribe under Article 194(2) of the Constitution of India?
Court Decision and Analysis: The Court inclined to agree with the submissions of the Amicus Curiae and Mr. Gopal Sankarnarayan, senior counsel, that the view expressed in the decision of the majority in PV Narasmiha Rao requires reconsideration by a larger Bench. Our reasons prima facie for doing so are formulated below:
(i) Firstly, the interpretation of Article 105(2) and the corresponding provisions of Article 194(2) of the Constitution must be guided by the text, context, and the object and purpose underlying the provision. The fundamental purpose and object underlying Article 105(2) of the Constitution are that Members of Parliament or, as the case may be, of the State Legislatures must be free to express their views on the floor of the House or to cast their votes either in the House or as members of the Committees of the House without fear of consequences.
While Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution recognizes the individual right to the freedom of speech and expression, Article 105(2) institutionalizes that right by recognizing the importance of the Members of the Legislature having the freedom to express themselves and to cast their ballots without fear of reprisal or consequences. In other words, the object of Article 105(2) or Article 194(2) does not prima facie appear to be to render immunity from the launch of criminal proceedings for a violation of the criminal law that may arise independently of the exercise of the rights and duties as a Member of Parliament or of the legislature of a state;
(ii) Secondly, in the course of the judgment in PV Narasmiha Rao, Justice S.C. Agarwal noted a serious anomaly if the construction in support of the immunity under Article 105(2) for a bribe-taker were to be accepted: a member would enjoy immunity from prosecution for such a charge if the member accepts the bribe for speaking or giving their vote in Parliament in a particular manner and in fact speaks or gives a vote in Parliament in that manner.
On the other hand, no immunity would attach, and the member of the legislature would be liable to be prosecuted on a charge of bribery if they accept the bribe for not speaking or for not giving their vote on a matter under consideration before the House but they act to the contrary. This anomaly, Justice Agarwal observed, would be avoided if the words “in respect of” in Article 105(2) are construed to mean ‘arising out of’.
In other words, in such a case, the immunity would be available only if the speech that has been made or the vote that has been given is an essential and integral part of the cause of action for the proceedings giving rise to the law;
(iii) Thirdly, the judgment of Justice SC Agarwal has specifically dwelt on the question as to when the offense of bribery would be complete. The judgment notes that the offense is complete with the acceptance of the money or when the agreement to accept the money is concluded and is not dependent on the performance of the illegal promise by the receiver.
The receiver of the bribe would be treated to have committed the offense even when he fails to perform the bargain underlying the tender and acceptance of the bribe. This aspect bearing on the constituent elements of the offense of a bribe finds elaboration in the judgment of Justice Agarwal but is not dealt with in the judgment of the majority.
The Bench has already noted above that efforts to seek a review of the judgment in PV Narasmiha Rao and later in proceedings under Article 32 of the Constitution were not successful. One of us (Justice Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud), while delivering a concurrent opinion for a Bench of five judges in Kalpana Mehta v. UOI India9 (para 221), had occasion to observe that should the correctness of the view in PV Narasmiha Rao fall for reconsideration in an appropriate case, a larger bench may have to consider the issue.
The view of the majority has serious ramifications for the polity and the preservation of probity in public life. For the above reasons, prima facie at this stage, the court considered the view that the correctness of the view of the majority in PV Narasmiha Rao should be reconsidered by a larger Bench of seven judges. The court accordingly requests the Registry to place the papers before the Chief Justice for constituting a larger Bench of seven judges.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with
Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very
good success. If you know of any please share. Kudos!
You can read similar text here: Blankets
Other than having elevated power and durability, Sunspot has immunity to all forms of heat, can survive with out meals or water, and can use thermal updrafts to fly.
sugar defender official website I’ve had problem with blood sugar changes for several years,
and it truly impacted my energy levels throughout the day.
Considering that beginning Sugar Defender, I feel more
balanced and alert, and I do not experience those afternoon drops any longer!
I love that it’s an all-natural remedy that functions without any rough side effects.
It’s really been a game-changer for me
Greetings, I think your website could possibly be having browser compatibility problems. Whenever I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening in I.E., it’s got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other than that, wonderful site!
Very good info. Lucky me I came across your site by accident (stumbleupon). I have bookmarked it for later.
I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I absolutely enjoyed every little bit of it. I’ve got you book-marked to check out new stuff you post…
You need to take part in a contest for one of the most useful sites on the web. I am going to highly recommend this web site!
The place can I discover custom-made gothic clothing for men?
Having read this I believed it was very informative. I appreciate you spending some time and energy to put this article together. I once again find myself spending a lot of time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worthwhile!
On March 18, the Pennsylvania Division of Health reported the state’s first dying related to the virus, a affected person at St.
Moreover, Barthez was highly regarded for his distinctive skills with the ball at his ft, in addition to his correct distribution along with his left foot, which enabled him to play the ball out from the again or launch an attack with his fast throws or long objective kicks; his confidence in possession typically led him to be involved in the construct-up of performs, and he usually operated outside the penalty space, and would even often attempt to dribble with the ball previous opposing strikers with feints resembling nutmegs or stepovers.
Nussbaum, Paul (April 4, 2011).
You get quite a lot of those who get elected they usually don’t know the way to run stuff.
But wait, let me ask you few questions?
Howdy! I could have sworn I’ve been to this web site before but after going through a few of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Regardless, I’m certainly pleased I discovered it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back frequently.
It’s difficult to find knowledgeable people about this subject, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
I really like it when people get together and share opinions. Great site, stick with it.
Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good.
Schad, Tom (August 22, 2023).
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you. https://accounts.binance.com/ur/register?ref=WTOZ531Y
There’s certainly a great deal to find out about this subject. I really like all of the points you’ve made.
MacDonald means that the identify Christie Devon may have been Alcott’s stage title during a stint with the Boston Theatre Firm, as the name appears in an inventory of the individuals.
Horti, Samuel (thirteen October 2018).
Because of the absence of Seigo Narazaki, Kawashima turned Nagoya Grampus’ first alternative goalkeeper at the beginning of the 2006 season.
I like looking through a post that can make people think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment.
I used to be able to find good advice from your content.
It’s hard to find well-informed people for this topic, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
Great blog you’ve got here.. It’s hard to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I seriously appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!
Hi there! I could have sworn I’ve visited this website before but after looking at many of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Anyhow, I’m definitely pleased I discovered it and I’ll be bookmarking it and checking back regularly.
I was extremely pleased to uncover this great site. I wanted to thank you for your time for this particularly wonderful read!! I definitely liked every part of it and i also have you book-marked to see new things on your web site.
You ought to be a part of a contest for one of the most useful websites on the web. I most certainly will highly recommend this web site!
Good post. I learn something new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon every day. It’s always interesting to read through content from other authors and use a little something from other websites.
You’re so interesting! I don’t suppose I’ve truly read something like that before. So good to find somebody with genuine thoughts on this subject matter. Really.. thanks for starting this up. This website is something that’s needed on the internet, someone with a little originality.
Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you, However I am encountering issues with your RSS. I don’t understand why I can’t join it. Is there anybody having similar RSS issues? Anyone who knows the answer can you kindly respond? Thanx!!
Everything is very open with a precise clarification of the challenges. It was really informative. Your website is extremely helpful. Thank you for sharing.
Hi, I do believe this is a great website. I stumbledupon it 😉 I’m going to come back once again since I book marked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.
Collection includes four stable-colored dishcloths and four traditional window pane plaid dishcloths out there in a variety of wealthy colours to coordinate with any kitchen décor.
I like it when people get together and share views. Great blog, continue the good work!
After I originally left a comment I seem to have clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get 4 emails with the exact same comment. Is there a way you can remove me from that service? Many thanks.
I’m very happy to uncover this website. I need to to thank you for your time due to this wonderful read!! I definitely appreciated every bit of it and i also have you saved as a favorite to check out new stuff in your site.
I blog frequently and I really appreciate your content. The article has really peaked my interest. I am going to book mark your site and keep checking for new details about once per week. I subscribed to your Feed too.
Hello! I could have sworn I’ve visited this blog before but after going through many of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Regardless, I’m definitely delighted I stumbled upon it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back regularly!
After looking over a handful of the blog articles on your website, I honestly appreciate your technique of writing a blog. I saved it to my bookmark site list and will be checking back soon. Please visit my website too and tell me how you feel.
You are so interesting! I do not suppose I have read something like that before. So great to find another person with some unique thoughts on this subject. Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This web site is something that’s needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality.
I want to to thank you for this wonderful read!! I certainly loved every bit of it. I’ve got you book marked to look at new things you post…
May I simply just say what a relief to find someone that genuinely knows what they’re talking about over the internet. You certainly know how to bring a problem to light and make it important. More people have to look at this and understand this side of the story. I was surprised that you’re not more popular since you certainly possess the gift.
Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this web site before but after looking at many of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Regardless, I’m certainly delighted I stumbled upon it and I’ll be bookmarking it and checking back often.
The economy was stabilised by the adoption of the Balcerowicz Plan in 1989, named after the principle author of the reforms, minister of finance Leszek Balcerowicz.
Excellent blog post. I certainly appreciate this site. Thanks!
Good blog post. I definitely appreciate this website. Continue the good work!
An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a colleague who has been conducting a little homework on this. And he actually bought me breakfast due to the fact that I found it for him… lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!! But yeah, thanks for spending some time to talk about this matter here on your blog.
The World Chess Championship 1886 was the first official World Chess Championship match contested by Wilhelm Steinitz and Johannes Zukertort.
Wonderful post! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our website. Keep up the good writing.
This is a topic that is close to my heart… Cheers! Exactly where can I find the contact details for questions?
I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment.
This is a topic that’s near to my heart… Many thanks! Where are your contact details though?
One ultimate observe on training: It will be important that your fence have what is understood because the invisible gate, equivalent to a driveway or sidewalk.
This is a topic that’s near to my heart… Thank you! Where are your contact details though?
Aw, this was an incredibly nice post. Spending some time and actual effort to create a really good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a whole lot and don’t seem to get anything done.
An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a co-worker who was doing a little research on this. And he actually bought me breakfast simply because I found it for him… lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending some time to discuss this issue here on your web site.
I like reading a post that can make people think. Also, many thanks for permitting me to comment.
Saved as a favorite, I really like your site.
Does something extra exotic stir your taste buds?
I love it when people get together and share views. Great site, continue the good work!
Manga Park can also be an important website that accommodates a big variety of mangas that can be found without spending a dime.
Spot on with this write-up, I actually feel this web site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be returning to see more, thanks for the information.
This is a topic that’s near to my heart… Thank you! Exactly where are your contact details though?
Can I just say what a relief to uncover a person that genuinely understands what they’re discussing on the web. You definitely know how to bring a problem to light and make it important. A lot more people have to check this out and understand this side of your story. I can’t believe you aren’t more popular since you definitely possess the gift.
After looking at a few of the blog posts on your web site, I honestly like your technique of blogging. I saved as a favorite it to my bookmark site list and will be checking back in the near future. Please visit my website as well and tell me what you think.
Everything is very open with a clear explanation of the issues. It was definitely informative. Your site is very helpful. Thank you for sharing!
Spot on with this write-up, I actually think this amazing site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the info!
I truly love your site.. Great colors & theme. Did you make this website yourself? Please reply back as I’m looking to create my very own website and would love to learn where you got this from or what the theme is named. Appreciate it.
I really like it when people get together and share ideas. Great blog, stick with it.
This is a topic which is close to my heart… Best wishes! Where are your contact details though?
It’s hard to find knowledgeable people in this particular topic, however, you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
Aw, this was an exceptionally good post. Taking the time and actual effort to create a superb article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and don’t manage to get anything done.
The largest benefit of shopping for fashion jewellery on-line is the saving of time, gas and the ability to check again on what you already personal before buying something.
I seriously love your blog.. Excellent colors & theme. Did you build this web site yourself? Please reply back as I’m trying to create my very own site and would love to learn where you got this from or what the theme is called. Kudos.
As such, the value of cash could inflate away – it is a type of paper wealth – nevertheless it is usually distinguished from stocks and bonds.