“Rarest of the Rare: Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980)”
Name of the case: – Bachan Singh vs State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684
Court: – Supreme Court of India
Case no.: – Criminal appeal no. 273 of 1979
Decided on: – 9th May 1980
Bench: – Justices Y.C. Chandrachud, A. Gupta, N. Untwalia, P.N Bhagwati, and R. Sarkaria
Introduction:
Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab stands as a pivotal case in Indian legal history, as it unfolded in 1980 and introduced the groundbreaking concept of the “rarest of rare” doctrine within the realm of the death penalty. The case centered around the murder of Desa Singh, Durga Bai, and Veeran Bai, with Bachan Singh receiving a death sentence. Following the affirmation of the death penalty by the Punjab High Court, Bachan Singh sought recourse in the Supreme Court, which granted him Special Leave.
The significance of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab extends beyond the individual case, as it laid down a comprehensive legal framework for the imposition of the death penalty in India. This landmark decision is widely recognized as a cornerstone in shaping the jurisprudence surrounding capital punishment within the country.
Central to the judgment was the assertion that the death penalty should be reserved for the rarest or most exceptional cases, where the alternative is unequivocally ruled out. The court’s emphasis on the “rarest of rare” doctrine has since become a guiding principle in determining when the imposition of the death penalty is justified. The impact of this decision reverberates through subsequent legal proceedings involving the death penalty, contributing significantly to the evolution of jurisprudence on this contentious issue. Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab stands as a key reference point in the ongoing discourse on capital punishment in India.
Background/Facts:
The Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab case unfolded against the backdrop of Bachan Singh’s earlier conviction for the murder of his wife, which led to a life imprisonment sentence. Following his release, a tragic turn of events occurred when Bachan Singh was implicated in the murders of Desa Singh, Durga Bai, and Veeran Bai. Subsequently charged under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, he faced a conviction and, notably, a death sentence.
Upon the confirmation of the death penalty by the Punjab High Court, Bachan Singh pursued an appeal that was denied. However, seeking further legal recourse, he petitioned the Supreme Court, which, in an unusual move, granted him Special Leave. This set the stage for a critical examination of the case’s nuances, particularly considering the requirement for “special reasons” under Section 354(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) for the imposition of the death penalty.
The case came under scrutiny before a five-judge bench of the Supreme Court, which delivered a landmark judgment introducing substantial limitations on the death penalty. The crux of their ruling lay in the establishment of the “rarest of the rare” doctrine, asserting that the death penalty should only be applied in exceedingly exceptional cases where alternative options are unequivocally ruled out.
This groundbreaking decision in Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab has earned recognition for its profound impact on the jurisprudence surrounding the death penalty in India. The judgment’s enduring influence is reflected in its role as a guiding principle in subsequent cases involving capital punishment, shaping the legal discourse, and providing a framework for the careful and circumspect application of the ultimate penalty.
Issues raised:
The Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab case presented a multifaceted legal challenge, prompting the judiciary to grapple with several critical issues. Central to the deliberations was the question of whether Bachan Singh’s case met the criteria of “special reasons” for the imposition of the death penalty, a prerequisite stipulated by Section 354(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). This requirement underscored the necessity for the court to carefully consider and articulate compelling justifications for resorting to the ultimate punishment.
Moreover, the judicial scrutiny extended beyond procedural matters to encompass constitutional dimensions. The court was confronted with the profound inquiry into whether the imposition of the death penalty aligned with the constitutional guarantee of the right to life as enshrined in Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. This aspect of the case delved into the delicate balance between the severity of the penalty and the foundational right to life, raising profound questions about the constitutionality of capital punishment.
The court’s landmark decision in response to these complex questions resulted in the formulation of the “rarest of the rare” doctrine. This doctrinal innovation marked a significant departure from routine practices surrounding the death penalty, imposing a stringent standard. It decreed that the ultimate punishment should be reserved exclusively for cases deemed as the most exceptional, where alternative options were unequivocally ruled out.
Crucially, the court’s ruling also introduced a procedural safeguard in the form of a balance sheet. Before imposing the death penalty, the court mandated the creation of a comprehensive record detailing both aggravating and mitigating circumstances. Notably, the court emphasized that mitigating factors should be accorded full weightage in this deliberative process. The objective was to strike a fair and judicious balance between the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, ensuring thorough and nuanced consideration before arriving at the grave decision of capital punishment.
The Bachan Singh case, therefore, emerges as a pivotal legal milestone, addressing not only the procedural prerequisites for the death penalty but also delving into its constitutional implications. The resulting “rarest of the rare” doctrine and the nuanced procedural guidelines have significantly shaped the jurisprudence surrounding capital punishment in India.
Actions taken:
In the landmark Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab case, the Supreme Court of India undertook a comprehensive examination of the death penalty’s constitutionality within the Indian legal framework. This pivotal legal episode saw the introduction of the groundbreaking “rarest of the rare” doctrine, a judicial innovation that fundamentally reshaped the criteria for imposing the death penalty. According to this doctrine, the court established stringent parameters, reserving the use of the death penalty exclusively for the most exceptional cases where alternative options were unequivocally foreclosed.
Furthermore, the court articulated a meticulous procedural safeguard in the form of a balance sheet. Before deciding on the imposition of the death penalty, the court mandated the creation of a detailed record cataloging both aggravating and mitigating circumstances. Notably, the court emphasized that mitigating factors should be afforded full weightage in this evaluative process. The objective was to ensure a judicious and equitable equilibrium between aggravating and mitigating circumstances, introducing a nuanced approach to the application of the ultimate punishment.
In addition to introducing these seminal principles, the Supreme Court took a firm stance on the constitutionality of the death penalty, affirming its legitimacy within the Indian legal system. However, this affirmation was accompanied by a judicious imposition of significant limitations on its application, reflecting a delicate balance between upholding the constitutional framework and acknowledging the gravity of the penalty.
The judgment rendered in the Bachan Singh case reverberates as a cornerstone decision, wielding a profound impact on the legal landscape surrounding the death penalty in India. Recognized as a landmark ruling, it has played a pivotal role in shaping and influencing the evolving jurisprudence pertaining to capital punishment in the country. The nuanced doctrinal innovations and procedural guidelines introduced in this case continue to serve as a touchstone for subsequent legal deliberations on matters of life and death within the Indian legal system.
Decision of the court:
In the pivotal legal saga of Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court of India delivered a landmark judgment that left an indelible mark on the constitutionality of the death penalty within the Indian legal framework. The court, in its deliberations, arrived at a nuanced position, wherein it affirmed the constitutionality of the death penalty while simultaneously introducing profound limitations on its application.
The cornerstone of the court’s decision was the introduction of the “rarest of the rare” doctrine, a judicial innovation that significantly altered the landscape of capital punishment in India. This doctrine, conceived by the court, established a formidable threshold, reserving the imposition of the death penalty exclusively for those cases deemed as the most exceptional, where alternative options were unequivocally ruled out. In doing so, the court sought to inject a judicious and discerning approach into the application of the ultimate punishment.
Crucially, the court recognized the imperative for a meticulous evaluation of circumstances surrounding the imposition of the death penalty. It mandated the creation of a comprehensive balance sheet, cataloging both aggravating and mitigating conditions. The court underscored the significance of according to full weightage to mitigating circumstances, emphasizing the need for a fair and equitable balance between the aggravating and mitigating factors. This procedural safeguard aimed to ensure thorough and careful consideration before arriving at the grave decision of imposing capital punishment.
The impetus for the court’s deliberations stemmed from the specific question of whether Bachan Singh’s case warranted “special reasons” for the imposition of the death penalty, as outlined in Section 354(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). The court’s response to this query not only set a precedent for the individual case but also laid down enduring principles that have since influenced the broader landscape of Indian criminal law.
Widely acknowledged as a significant milestone, the judgment in the Bachan Singh case is credited for its instrumental role in shaping and advancing the jurisprudence surrounding the death penalty in India. The intricate doctrinal nuances and procedural guidelines introduced by the court continue to serve as a touchstone for legal discourse on matters of life and death within the Indian legal system.
Conclusion:
In the pivotal legal drama that unfolded in Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court of India delivered a landmark judgment that not only left an enduring imprint on the constitutionality of the death penalty but also introduced a change in basic assumptions in its application within the Indian legal framework. In a judicious balancing act, the court, through meticulous deliberations, affirmed the constitutionality of the death penalty while concurrently implementing significant constraints on its usage.
At the heart of the court’s groundbreaking decision was the inception of the “rarest of the rare” doctrine—a visionary judicial construct that fundamentally reshaped the terrain of capital punishment in India. This pioneering doctrine, conceived by the court, erected a substantial threshold, reserving the sanction of the death penalty exclusively for cases deemed the most exceptional, where alternative avenues were unequivocally precluded. In introducing this doctrine, the court aimed to instill a discerning and judicious dimension into the application of the ultimate punishment.
Of paramount importance was the court’s recognition of the necessity for a scrupulous examination of circumstances surrounding the imposition of the death penalty. The court prescribed the formulation of a comprehensive balance sheet, meticulously cataloging both aggravating and mitigating conditions. Notably, the court stressed the imperative of assigning full weightage to mitigating circumstances, underscoring the need for a fair and equitable equilibrium between aggravating and mitigating factors. This procedural safeguard was instituted to ensure a thorough, thoughtful, and fair evaluation before arriving at the solemn decision of imposing capital punishment.
The impetus for the court’s profound deliberations arose from the specific question of whether Bachan Singh’s case warranted “special reasons” for the imposition of the death penalty, as articulated in Section 354(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). The court’s response to this pivotal inquiry not only set a precedent for the individual case but also established enduring principles that have resonated throughout the broader landscape of Indian criminal law.
Recognized universally as a significant milestone, the judgment in the Bachan Singh case is acknowledged for its instrumental role in shaping and advancing the jurisprudence surrounding the death penalty in India. The intricate doctrinal subtleties and procedural guidelines introduced by the court serve as a guiding beacon in legal discussions concerning matters of life and death within the Indian legal system, continuing to influence and shape subsequent deliberations on this weighty subject.
Potential questions this judgement tends to answer:
The judgment in the Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab case tends to answer several potential questions, including:
-
Whether the facts found by the lower courts would be considered “special reasons” for awarding the death penalty as required under Section 354(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)?
-
What are the limitations on the application of the death penalty in India and under what circumstances can it be imposed?
-
How should the aggravating and mitigating circumstances be balanced before imposing the death penalty?
-
What is the constitutionality of the death penalty in India, and does it violate the right to life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution?
-
What is the significance of the “rarest of the rare” doctrine introduced in this case, and how has it influenced the jurisprudence pertaining to the death penalty in India?
These are some of the potential questions that the judgment in the Bachan Singh case addresses, and the case is considered a landmark decision that has significantly shaped the legal framework surrounding the death penalty in India.
WRITTEN BY: Pankhuri Rastogi
Unfold Law – Law Firm in Bangalore, Lawyers in Bangalore
🔍 Explore the landmark case of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) with Unfold Law! 📜⚖️ Learn about the “rarest of the rare” doctrine and its impact on Indian jurisprudence surrounding the death penalty. #LegalHistory #CapitalPunishment
Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a
great author.I will always bookmark your blog and will often come back
down the road. I want to encourage you to ultimately continue your great work,
have a nice weekend!
My blog post … vpn coupon code 2024
Wow, this paragraph is fastidious, my younger sister
is analyzing such things, therefore I am going to convey her.
My web site vpn special coupon code 2024
I am going to tell you the biggest news till now if you live in Delhi then this is a very good opportunity for you to meet me and have sex with me because I live alone here and work in Delhi Escorts Sexual Agency. I work as a Delhi call girl and if you want to meet me personally then you have to WhatsApp me at 8826294199 and you can meet me at any hotel or flat because I can come anywhere.
Hi there! Would you mind if I share your blog
with my twitter group? There’s a lot of people
that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know.
Many thanks
My page :: facebook vs eharmony to find love online
I’m gone to convey my little brother, that he should also pay a
quick visit this web site on regular basis to take updated from latest gossip.
Also visit my web-site: eharmony special coupon code 2024
Hi everyone, it’s my first pay a quick visit at this site, and paragraph is really fruitful for me,
keep up posting such articles.
Visit my blog; nordvpn special coupon code 2024
Great Post! Thanks for sharing such amazing information with us. Please keep sharing.
e-commerce Supply Chain
Great Post! Thanks for sharing such amazing information with us. Please keep sharing.
order fulfillment services usa
Call girls in Jodhpur is promising to give you as much as can be expected from a female buddy
Each man dreams of having a sensual and electrifying experience with a delightful and ultra-hot call young lady in Indore. Lovemaking is a most excellent process is made by the all-powerful, from that point forward we have been getting a charge out of this with our affection one or second half, it gives you more delight than anything can give in this world. A platitude by an extraordinary competitor that immaculate sustenance and an impeccable night can give the stature of your objectives, and it appears to be excessively flawless and well stated, when we have a fulfilled body and a fulfilled personality then your endeavors begin giving you organic products, and to make you fulfilled and to give you physical joy call girls in Indore are passing on, simply come to us. call girl in jodhpur
The most necessary factor within the sex service is the seduction of male sexual desire. Escorts service in Siliguri is aware of the importance of seduction and our women are trained and cherished to burst out a person through sexy seduction techniques. Our Escort buckled down for his or her welfare. They are the welfare oddity, and they love yoga, heart-stimulating exercise, rec center to stay up their exclusive category figure. They are astounding in ability, approach, uncommon exercises, uncommon stances and last not the minimum sex positionssiliguri escorts service
They can assist in reducing stress in the body, which tends to be a result of work hours. In addition, if they are planning to host parties or corporate events, they can employ escorts to attend the event. Customers can enjoy their entire day and night in these Ludhiana escorts in which they are able to indulge in sexual desires.
The escorts have a lot of their own way as they are able to be distinctive among clients and can be used in any issue regarding services. If you are able to stick by using an escort, you’ll see a variety of modifications to your life that you’re not experiencing within your marital relationship. A few of the exclusive services offered by escorts consist of out-call as well as in-call contact services. They also provide the option of sexually intense massages that ensure that your body and mind system are totally at ease. You’ll feel energetic after using their services. The services offered by them are able to attract the attention of customers to use in a single glance.
Ludhiana escort service
They are able to accompany you to the most renowned girls are accompanied by a calm and smug attitude as well as providing the most wonderful personal service. Our girls are able to meet you at the airport mortal and guide you to your destination or hotel. Please inform us of any basic questions whenever you call, and we’ll arrange for the young lady to arrive at your desired set. We also arrange transportation and hotel reservations. Our escort service is an amazing symbol of grandeur in Ludhiana.
Ludhiana escort service
The satisfaction of our clients ranks our wealth. We guarantee that you get high-end female escorts in our society. All the ladies in our office are completely robust, fit and fabulous to meet your requirements. The ladies are hot, hot, sexy, likely, cool, refreshing state of mind, beautiful, strong and sexually attractive. Be sure you’re sure to have a pleasant time with these ladies.
Jalandhar escort service
Why are you waiting in limbo? Call or email us to make an appointment for your young lady escort and find a gorgeous woman for a low cost. We are always ready to assist you in your journey towards the location in Amritsar. We’re currently in a position of trust and offer Escorts in Amritsar to give you a genuine advantage throughout the decades.
Our company is the sole independent escort service in Jammu that can help to meet the woman you want you spend some time with. We connect with girls of various backgrounds, ethnicities, talents and ages, from college students to professional homemakers to models and famous. All you need to do is create your choice. Select what you’d like. Select the person you’d like to spend time with. Also, contact us.
Privacy is a two-way street. We understand that you don’t want to discuss in public your relationship with your escort. The same is true for our escorts who aren’t keen to talk about their careers as well as the things they do in private. You want to return to your normal routine after being with an escort for a while. The same way Patiala escorts want to live a life after having met you.
It’s best if you feel comfortable in the vicinity of these gorgeous beauties. Calendar escort girls may be brought in for a variety of occasions, including office parties, birthday celebrations as well as business meetings and other social events.
Bathinda escort service
If you want to enjoy sex then you should hire the young girls of Delhi Call Girls and try all 69 positions on the bed with them because these girls of Delhi Russian Call Girls are very experienced, you can make them do any position on the bed, they are ready to do all this and yes, in today’s time, girls like to have sex in the doggy style. If you are having sex with your sexual partner in the old way then you should change your position because, in today’s time, there are many options in sex and girls also like them a lot. And if you satisfy them in bed then these girls will be your slaves for life.
In the era of rapid technological advancement, the education landscape is undergoing a profound transformation
Escort Service in Connaught Place | 369+ Call Girls @ ₹6K-18K Full night cash · Connaught Place Call Girls – Experience the reliability in Escort Service.
Thank you for the good writeup It in truth was a leisure accountit Look complicated to more introduced agreeable from you!By the way, how could we keep up a correspondence?
Delhi Model Escort Service in Delhi
Delhi call girls Service in Delhi
Top Escorts Service in Delhi
Delhi Service Escorts Service in Delhi
Independent russian escorts Service Delhi
This is a very good post. I liked reading your blog. Keep writing like this in future as well so that we keep getting good knowledge and information.
Bikes on rent in Chandigarh
Thank you for creating such an amazing blog! We absolutely love the insightful content and can’t wait to read more. Keep up the fantastic work!
kedarkantha trip package
I am an adventurous and hot Anjuna Beach who is looking for an opportunity to spice up your night. I can provide you with a range of sensual Independent Escort in Anjuna Beach . Let me be your queen tonight and you can be my king. I am at your disposal you can have all your erotic wishes fulfilled with me. Just one night with me all your dreams would come true. So, come on and book me to make your night extra special.
Nice blog. Great information_ Hinjewadi Call Girls _ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information_ Pimple Saudagar Escorts Call Girls _ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Aundh Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Bavdhan Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Pimpri-Chinchwad Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Aundh Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Pune Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Pune Escorts Call Girls __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Hotel Escorts In Koregaon Park __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Best Hotel Escorts In Pune __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Nice blog. Great information__ Shivaji Nagar Hotel Escorts __ It’s really helpful. Valuable content and presentation.
Learn about the “rarest of the rare” doctrine and its impact on Indian jurisprudence surrounding the death penalty.
hyderabad escorts
A great cricket betting platform is one that is mobile friendly. You can bet anywhere and anytime through your phone. This means that you can easily change your strategy during the match.
https://www.onlineidbetting.com/
Thanks for share us a great information.
https://www.yamya.co.in/
Whether you’re just facing minor bumps or major obstacles in your relationship journey, hope exists around every corner—including finding true love at RK Shastri’s doorstep! Embrace this opportunity for healing and rediscovery in your romantic endeavors +91-7579854785 https://www.bestloveproblemsolution.com/